Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2015-0407 Documents Submitted at Mtg ohs Ityu WV April 7, 2015 Presented by David Helmich 468 Williamson Way Ashland, OR 97520 ashlandsolar@d-pminc.com Intro Good evening. I'm Dave Helmich. I live at 468 Williamson Way in Ashland. I'm semi- retired here but continue with my career as VP and Chief Engineer of Solvida Design and Engineering. Solvida furnishes the full range of design services to the solar industry and particularly to developers of PV Solar Parks. This is the presentation of a citizen, however, not my employer. Members of our community are promoting the partial development of the Imperatrice property, City owned, across the freeway, above the port of entry for the beginnings of a solar park. This property could support as much as 100 Mw of solar power. We would like to see an immediate concrete step toward at least some significant solar power to be generated there in furtherance of City policies - preparing for climate change and being proactive in upgrade of City facilities. We are suggesting a much smaller start, not 100 Mw, perhaps only 5 Mw. 5 Mw would require only 25 acres of the 860 acre site, leaving the balance available for grazing, conservancy, recreation or other possible uses, including possible additional solar park modules in the future. 5 Mw is the equivalent of 2,000 average size residential rooftop installations. For free! Without selling anything! All residents' benefit, not just those who can afford it! The current grazing contract for the site would not be expected to be affected. Feasibility In the past 3 decades, I participated in the design of possibly 100 industrial solar projects, generally for private investors, but also including major utilities, such as the LA DWP, East Bay MUD and AC Transit. With land control and the appropriate solar exposure, these projects can make financial sense now. And a project could be constructed with no capital or operating cost to the City. Ashland is living in an electrical energy wonderland. One audit states that our sweet deal with the BPA nets the City $1.5 million annually for non-electrical utility uses. And we still have power at nearly the lowest rates anywhere. So, how can we responsibly reduce our carbon footprint with virtually no financial outlay and no rate burden on our citizens? One way, certainly not the only way: The City could lease the 25 or so acres required to a private developer for, say, 20 years. This developer would reap the tax benefits available only to a business, thereby reducing the net capital cost of the project. The rent we would receive for our (currently underutilized) property could be a royalty on the power sales. We could have the project for our own account at the end of the lease or sell it assuming the earth has stopped warming. Under this particular scenario, the power would be sold to Pacific Power (its transmission lines traverse the site) at its avoided cost. Under law, PP must allow the connection and take the power up to 5 Mw. They may wish more, in which case that could be proposed. PP's avoided cost (set by the State) is likely at least double what we pay to BPA as a municipal utility. Whether a project(s) would be financially viable would fall out in the proposals received. To pre-suppose success is required. The rational way to proceed is for proposers to determine within bounds the physical and financial structure(s) acceptable to them and for the City to reject or accept them based on City values. Proposal Urgency We propose the City fund the production by outside consultants of the technical side of an RFP requesting proposals from financially qualified development applicants to begin the PV park development. It is urgent this RFP be developed now in the face of likely termination of federal tax benefits next year. It is further urgent this be approved in this year's budget cycle since the next City budget opportunity would be 2 years from now. The minimal aim of the RFP would be set purposely low, that is, as little as 5 Mw, with an intent to actually begin the development process as soon as an acceptable proposal is received and agreed upon by the City. This is to qualify for current tax incentives. RFP The RFP is broadly conceived to minimize delay to a developer. It will involve much more than "make us a deal." It is intended to, for example: • Complete geotechnical studies in advance to reduce the unknowns (and contingency markups) that a proposer would be faced with. • Identify interconnection issues in advance and tailor options for minimal resistance. • Identify and complete any environmental studies that would be required, including archaeological studies, to the extent those can be fit in the RFP timeline. • Identify several preliminary site designs that could be useful for a proposer The RFP content would be expected to allow a project proposer to invest minimal effort in understanding the site's physical limitations and potential and to allow for a more complete understanding of possible financial structure(s) it might propose for a project up there. I have identified more than 3 firms interested in competing to prepare such an RFP. There are more. I have identified at least 5 firms interested in responding to such an RFP. There are more. Thank you for you kind attention. Complete Summary of the Ashland. Renewable Energy.Acquisition Department (AREAD) In Four Speeches (Guide to speech videos on page 5) Here are the texts of all four speeches: 1. Introduction to AREAD Get out of my density restraining Global warming is bad. unprotected human bodies in harm's way Global-warming is really bad. Hospital emergencies Global warming is terrible scary bad. More crime Disasters are happening. Unemployment People are losing it. Higher Utility bills Climate-change is ALREADY here Water bills with more disasters on the way. More over amped We accidentally created a Pipes monster carbon blanket pile-up. Wires Water treatment plants The "least" we can do is STOP adding MORE. Impossible local food production And on and on Can't do the cars and factories from here. Inequities and miseries exponentially cannibalizing the quality of life which now can be But we CAN "magnificently" STOP COLD identified, measured, and priced. the gonnabe problem homes and buildings that are designed to spew atrocious amounts Oh, and don't forget the carbons. of carbon causings for the next 100 years. And the monster stranded investments. In short Ashland has been wasting Oh, whoops. $7 million dollars a year to ruin That would ruin our economy. the atmosphere 30 times faster than not. Surprise Stopping bad growth We HAVE TO stop adding houses, buildings, doesn't ruin our economy at all. and the externalities they bring. Ashlanders actually pay 2 times more Let's put a moratorium on all dirty growth. to suffer new construction then they don't. Effective today. And be done with it. In other words, new construction costs everybody twice the money it brings in. Government salaries can now be spent on energy engineers to install megawatts of solar, run And fairness, it is not. cutting- edge upgrade programs, and generate intelligent You see, It's the ever increasing environmental Structural Wattage destinations. externalities A fantastic future. Road hazard Rush hours The Ashland Renewable Energy Acquisition Frantic driving Department would then oversee planning. Intersection mass stampedes 1 And who's going to put all this together. and finally, if necessary, drawing straws Yours truly. (with the option to go to the end of the line). So the heck with sustainability talk. The city would hire an experienced managing Anemic green washing. Energy Performance Contractor Barely-hanging-on. to hand-pick from WORKING-local-carpenters Getting used to it. 10 applicants who would be Or simply accepting defeat. meticulously trained and thoroughly equipped with Best the Ashland Renewable Energy Acquisition advanced education modules, Department as a priority. With Huelz as director. updated procedural techniques, and cutting-edge specialty tools. Putting up to 10 MWs of Energy upgrading your homes. These brand new techniques and tools And teaching true Structural Wattage growth. will increase performance-per-time effectiveness So call your counselors. Call the mayor. 5 times over what is now existing, Appoint Huelz. enabling a true Ashland Community Development Director. market transformation at cost. And let's get started by cost-effectively leasing Tesla A Home Performance Contractor electric cars for all the counselors can walk into your house, so we can quickly learn where we're all going to. do a walk through with you, And what it feels like to be going the right way. setup his measuring equipment, share with you a video IR camera performance MEASURING walk through, print out a detailed itemized sequence 2. Home Energy Upgrades of cost-effective measures, arrange a no-money-down loan payment plan, On Jan 6th, I briefly described the identical to your current utility payment plan, Ashland Renewable Energy Acquisition and guarantee the entire set of results. Department All-in under 2 hours. as a drop-in replacement for the planning department. Then, To complete an all-at-one-time comprehensive This format consists of three divisions: 40 percent energy reduction, Expedited solar panel installations, the construction itself requires an average of 5 Home energy upgrades, and days Zero-net-energy destinations. With a loan pay back time of between 7 and 15 years, The home energy upgrade program is after which the savings increase, especially exciting, your home has accumulated value, as it accomplishes effectiveness the upgraders get REALLY GOOD never before achieved. at what they're doing, and you've eclipsed the dreaded retrofit dabblings. This is because ALL existing homes and buildings in Ashland Also hired is an MBA loan expert, will receive energy upgrades paperwork manager, with the first being: and crew scheduler. Empty homes for sale, Why all the cutting-edge to do? Then those of policy people, Because the 100 full-time contractors, subs, and Then those eager to have an upgrade, suppliers 2 fully-employed for the entire 25 years necessary to environmentally and morally upgrade ALL the homes and buildings in Ashland) providing a solid foundation for the would reduce Ashland's structural-energy needs hopefully doable planet Earth. 40 percent across the board, conveniently creating clean energy for something else. 3. Structural Wattage Learning Center Although these upgrades themselves do NOT require any incentives, as they cost At the Jan. 6th & Feb. 3rd public forums, the HOMEOWNER only 5 cents a k-watt-hour, I introduced the they DO require Ashland to staff these two Ashland Renewable Energy Acquisition new people, and those two would replace Department our current energy conservation division and it's 3 important decarbonizing divisions: which is, and has been, buying efficiency at $1 per k-watt-hour 1. City policy procured Solar Generators, for the last 10 years. 2. A Home Energy Upgrade program, and now the 3. Structural Wattage learning center. This division only measures electrically heated homes and then leaves. The Structural Wattage Learning Center uses Of those measured, only 3 percent go on to call absolutely the best-in-the-world ultimate a part-time, minimally trained, zero-net-energy-generation design to construct hopefully somewhat equipped weatherizer a mixed-use retail shop right downtown who can only dabble with improvements. easily gotten to from the regular tourist walk and easily recognized by it's awesome solar roof. And since Bonneville only incentivizes certain dabbles, they seem to get done Upon entering, you would see a sectional whether the home needs it or not. cut-away of the 2-foot thick R-70 wall assembly, All this, combined with redundant paper work A fully functional hands-on model is the cause of the $1 per k-watt-hour of the automatic window coverings, efficiency acquisition price. An animation of the entire solar-roof Furthermore, voltage-switching options for space heating, the half-million-dollar/yr conservation division electric vehicle charging, or both, would need to spend an entire $15M a year SIMPLY to cancel-out the planning department's A view of the actual utility room fascination with biligerently fossilizing tracing the air-to-water heat pump and it's various this wonderful town with water tank heat tank battery modes, typewriter and carbon-paper reruns, complimented with And of course, a real-time, see through ever so innocent fresh-air heat-recovery-ventilator showing what-ever-you-say green-washings. air movement through the transfer channels which can be adjusted by your very own breathing. And then add to that the $7M from the dangerizing externalities The floors above of real estate gotta-grow before gotta learn. would be overnight accommodations And then, add on top of that, with more information, the coming cost of climate change. hands-on with the actual equipment, and topped-off with a tour of the solar roof's I remind you the Ashland the various attic configurations. Renewable Energy Acquisition Department simply stops all new construction in Ashland Since this is the world's first and in its place administers a 30 times greater most desperate global-warming carbon reduction solution, demonstration solution that actually 3 functions perfectly, I introduced the Ashland both creating money and Renewable Energy Acquisition Department stabilizing the'future planet Earth, and it's 3 decarbonizing divisions: it would be worth experiencing up-close and personal. 1. A Home Energy Upgrade program, 2. A Structural Wattage learning center, and now And what if the Department of Energy 3. City Policy Procured Solar Generators. chipped in on this monsterous learning event with instrumented data-logging verifications. Solar generators are roof-mounted solar panels One can only dream the sooner the better. and/or free-standing panel-arrays ground-mounted in yards or unused fields. Until then, there's a video to be found at YouTube Structural Wattage. Although these solar generators produce clean energy dependably for the next 30 to 50 years, And if you can get through the uber professional they have to be paid for all at once, presentation, and if you go so far as to from the get-go. study and research this Structural Wattage YouTube video In other words, the purchaser actually has to to the point of thorough understanding, pre-pay for 30 years of electricity. you'll confidently be on top of the whole subject. And that's a lot of up-front capital. What we're seeing here is a progression. Creative financing to the rescue. Throughout ancient history, the extra-human power source was wood. Thankfully, in the US there are dozens of And then we found coal, financial mechanisms, precisely designed which took a hundred years to integrate. to enable solar for every income bracket. and then we discovered gas, with new and improved methods introduced which took a hundred years to integrate. regularly. and now we've arrived at technology, The one requirement is which'll need a hundred years to integrate. A properly-facing sturdy roof. The only problem is, we've only got 20 years To date however, in Ashland, to deploy the renewable energy transition the only financial arrangement used has been the in order to avoid cooking the planet. simplist of all direct buy where the well-to-do owner can only Global warming solutions are here, purchase the installation for his own roof, but all, including everybody, with his own cash, leveraging his own tax liability, has to learn them pronto. and the city's cash grants. No matter what they look like or feel like. In other words, quicker than faster. Ashland has acquired a total of 1/2 megawatt in this way. Aesthetics are important. The only trouble is, Ashland should have Learning new aesthetics needs happen. already acquired 5 megawatts by now. And aesthetics are already changing. For instance, to spy an entire Again, creative financing to the rescue. solar panel roof, consisting of only solar panels, At this time, the three best financial what a welcome sight. mechanisms for solarizing any-and-all group properties in Ashland are: 1.The third-party tax-equity pass-through 4. City Policy Procured Solar Generators ownership 2.Community solar cooperative group buy, and the At the Jan. 6th, Feb. 3rd and 17th public forums, 3.Property assessed clean energy bonds 4 All are most complicated. And necessitate mountains of paperwork. Choosing one or two or three of these as a city policy for the duration would be great, Video Guide to All Four Speeches but the returns would quickly become sub-optimal comprising the complete summary of the and need to be constantly reinvented. Ashland Renewable Energy Acquisition Department Therefore, the best city policy would be to hire an expert MBA type, experienced in solar financing to stay on top of the best methods 1. "Introduction to AREAD" 3 min. and combinations of methods. Ashland.or.us On left go down to videos, City Meetings Archives, January 6, And the Up-Level picture gets even more complex. Takes you to vp.telvue. Wait. A chapter tab will appear, Chapter 8. Washington may or may not continue the federal tax credits, 2. "Home Energy Upgrade Program" 4Min. The state is trying-out a number of new policy Ashland.or.us On left go down to videos, rules City Meetings Archives, Feb. 3, The environmental externalities acknowledged Takes you to vp.telvue. Wait, true value of solar A chapter tab will appear, may become monetized at any time, Chapter 4, min. 52-56 and the inevitable carbon tax would definitely rewrite everything across the board. 3. "Structural Wattage Learning Center" 5 min. Ashland.or.us On left go down to videos, Chase, Morgan Stanley, Citigroup and on and on City Meetings Archives, Feb. 17, the big banks and their buddies Takes you to vp.telvue. Wait, have already signed up. A chapter tab will appear, Chapter 5 There's plenty of money out there eager 4. "City Policy Procured Solar Generators" 5 min. to invest in solar right now. Ashland.or.us On left go down to videos, We just gotta go get it. City Meetings Archives, March 3 Organize it. Takes you to vp.telvue. Wait, and bring it on home. A chapter tab will appear, Chapter 6 And here, getting on with it, And don't forget, Ashland would be appropriately just-in-time Google "Structural Wattage" to retire it's solar incentive program all together, (YouTube "Structural Wattage") with one single exception: youtube.com/channel/UCIm-SSXivesYbta9-E-TMgg Every year, the residential or roof with the biggest panel array, most perfectly https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nhdCRpbWXRg aimed,producing the most energy, would win an up-front cash grant for 30 Please watch the entire hour percent of the total installation cost and be to the point of understanding. You can do it. given the first prize for environmental leadership. Understanding these energy movement fundamentals will prepare you with a rock-solid basis protecting you from the barage of complications, both real and frivolous, coming at you soon. There will be a test. 5 Secretary of Energy, US Department of Energy, clearly sums up the current situation. (13min.) Search YouTube for: "Topic: Energy Technology and Innovation Speaker: Ernest Moniz" or (copy and paste both lines together as one link) http://m.youtube.com/watch?t=1 m24s&feature= youtu.be&v=j-pOz2e6reg (Texts of all 4 AREAD speeches above) 6 4/ill5 U ~D O N -sue r.+ April 7, 2015 Ashland City Council 20 East Main Street Ashland, OR. 97520 Mayor Stromberg and Councilors: Travel Oregon has a significant interest in the potential positive impacts of a safety rest area facility as proposed for your consideration. We understand the matter is before Ashland City Council for determination on whether or not to provide water and sewer service to the facility through an agreement with ODOT. While not a party to that agreement, we believe the public will be well served with a safety rest area south of Ashland and support ODOT's efforts to this end. It's our understanding there is interest in seeing that a defibrillator be placed in the Welcome Center as well as providing places for people to charge mobile devices. We believe both of those requests make sense and are happy to do our part in providing these along with the other amenities to serve visitors. Travel Oregon is responsible for the system of State Welcome Centers and we approach this responsibility with purpose and efficiency in mind as well as keeping service to the traveling public at the forefront of our decisions. We take our responsibility to steward the resource we're entrusted with seriously and operate the system of Welcome Centers according to visitor demand, striving for continued improvements. As provided in previous testimony, we believe the opportunity for placement of a first class Welcome Center at Oregon's Southern entrance on 1-5 would be an important component of the overall visitor services we offer. If we believed Welcome Centers and visitor centers were no longer relevant to travelers, we would not be supportive of the project, nor would we have entered into a long-term lease with ODOT ensuring a visitor-facing component in the overall facility. As provided previously in testimony, it is our belief, based on ODOT traffic estimates, that we will have an opportunity to interact with thousands of travelers at the proposed facility. This is another chance to welcome visitors to our state, provide way-finding assistance, introducing them to Oregon attractions, events, and points of interest all in an effort to make their trip to Oregon truly memorable. We want to optimize the economic impacts of tourism and believe interacting with visitors in a personal way serves that purpose. We do this through our website, campaigns, by providing collateral materials and with face-to-face interactions. Oregon Tourism Commission, 250 Church Street SE Suite loo, Salem, OR 97301,503.967.156o, fax: 503.967.1579 OREGON. WE LOVE DREAMERS.8 Until the facility is open, we can only speak to what we do at the other centers and speculate on what we anticipate for this proposed facility. During the period of May-September throughout the system, our state Welcome Centers are open 7 days per week-we anticipate this proposed center would be open 7 days per week as well. During the months of October through April, hours of staffed service are established based on visitor demand. To be clear, It is our expectation that the proposed Welcome Center will be open every month of the year- but the days and hours of staffed service from October through April will not be determined until the center is open and thus allows us to determine need, and demand on services. We can say definitively that barring technology issues or other factors outside our control, Wifi, print information and collateral brochures will be available every day that the rest area is open to the public. Thank you for the opportunity to provide additional comment on this matter, Jeff Hampton Travel Oregon 0 N O O CL in a~ N C O C V C7 aJ a) a) a) aJ a) a) to tko on L L L L L L L ~ Q Q Q Q Q Q Q O v-i ~ O QJ N v 'a -a a, a) coo Q _ f0 f6 C N N N_ a+ CIA d 3 L ro n L V) V) m o •U L a~ N Q L Vi m :3 4~ C C L • C t hA Q a) a a' 3 a p p M~ X p U to C O i L aJ +J +J m •2 r-+ .N > ° O O O U O v Vf O V1 m U C aJ U O N +J M U M a 3 V) aJ cn Q c M N v a) O 4J L -a LJ O n a, V) Q o L tin s u p a, E t E o o Ln +1 41 O U M Q U > ~o v Q p c U Q U C aJ L o VI L L 4- U (O L C CL (1) M aJ O u (1) ~ O O C - y Q O N +J aJ N O bD U C N 4' ~ U Q 12 p L .M L Q L (3j m 4~ "O L + O + la fa pp a 3 Fj -0 C ca - s a1 4~ O i L- 41 'p i2 -@ C W 41 3 C a) a) - t a, C m 4- 'moo C un :3 m 0 :Lo •on u C o 3 o a CU E L 3 o c a 3 c W C C Q -a ~ U Q L C Lr- -0 rp O u 'E Ln , > a C O O W a; 01 C O Zj 4- Vi N V) V V) O . Vf C C aJ •V ~ U N p ~ C N c o L O f6 -Z- CL = 3 Q O o C N L FO OU O U V) i~ 41 U •N N O M L 7 a1 ) CU Y ca M = N 7 + O C M Q M CL L C U N 3 -a > N VI > O ~ ~ ' O V) > a) m CU tic m C O U O -n m C C O C C w L >Q j a U Vf "O o x a) p m L Q o Q Q- L of c O O O cu aj > Cu C a U M 1.H Q Q 0 Q M 41 > +1 V) L O ~ O M m Q m L U O E a~ to o co p 3 N on > +aL41) - C o (B •U Q N C i C 4J a) "O i U O a M C _ Ln L _ i ~ o m o -a C c m In Ln 3 -Fo L- r_ 3 c O a~n' a on N o y o- to a) cu E .2 a o OU c i O L O O N a) p is L- L a) a1 o 41 , aJ a + O Q- o 'C w L w "a ~ in _ C u J- m Er o j-. ~m+ aJ aJ 7 O > C O aJ a1 p ca C aJ ca u lo O O m V) M L N a a {n N L V1 L C > U 3 L H I r-I N M lt* Ln lD r- d o y y fl-L, 7 s s 0 O v Q) IO % O d 07 d d I f6 w0 ~G O~ S' ~ ~ ~ G '~'GO✓ .n ~S 3~ of G -d ~ ~ co 3 (0 o) o .0 o s ~O T O d G s d o A-j 0 IS s s o 9 A-J co o o - k~, o o s O -a G s a '3 n, G O 3 a~ o r o m o o~ 3 w 7 O y O d = .a ° N co Ali O np s G G y 7i O aD r o o O A y co V G G '00 V G✓ o O O c0 N y 0 O w NG c0 d s N d 6D 7 G O O- y y N N r ty d ~ d I O T J+ ~ DA O I *01 a7 ~ a~ S d *G Q 0- D 'o T G u r y r -0 S v r; G M d '515 O w oa ca -a V V U co V N 70 N s 0) 0 S y tb v 4 4 -o O~~G9 d I -a 0 nA a~ s a'~ ca t6 N 4-, G i G 0 0 N 7j O N C-1 0 -a IT s o m O G G 9 o ✓ O 'rG 0) O ca N -d co m s G N 4-1 O s 3 to Q- CJ L 'ia V IO on Ln o d -a o p. s tin s Q *0 r- co 0 7 5 d G co c6 % ~G O c0 N io v is ',t6 N G ~n CO a) o A 5 0 o G @-0 t0 O % -0 d s t1 CO . 0 CO 7 S G y G I %O G CO d G G~ 0. G O N-0 C. v 0) _ s o O 47 CO -(0 ✓ O C s O 3 v d V s N O O 0 y d S- y s y U N v ~ 0.. 7 G 0D N ' f- 7 N N G Y R d N Q U to GO oA ~ ~ O O o G 7 G" yc G op N p? ✓ d co y O- y v d co ''G co d • d c0 -O 3 t> U N N o y O cY s d y oA d ✓ v CO y 0 d co ~s d d a p 90 cGO O o 3 o y a -a s s O s G G CO X- CO s m Q '.,`A oD aM O p co 7i o~ p' r -0 0 s ° s ~G op y o s' ~o 0 co 0 -0 r- i m G G w Y Q co ON ~G v u 'O' 7i a v Cl) a a s aD N t-' 6 `Z S ro o • ~ rz o o ro ro e, ~ tJ+ ~ ~ ~ ~ 'v+ 6Q aQ N L n> i i 4 (ID ro ro ro VD n ro O LP et V1, p ~ O n (~p O~ 00 V+ cr ro CID 04 Lp n .0 -0 ro o i ? ro O N to O 15 p 0- we %'D ~O y =i ro(~0 1 p~ V~ -~O e' O 2 O rt -4 ro fl- CAD . ro O N O y 0° N N' CAD O d CAD tD d N CAD ('D O r n y s O O S 'O p t1- O N O O 00 tp ro v+ n> n C5 % O LIN N O G N r'' n Cf~ ro S 'a pe CD O n0 O p O~ ~S o ID o p 0 .1 ° VD . 4, C: O u ,r, O -t Oi n G'Q g. 6 ro ro ro (ID iv O p e+ ^ N ro c~D m 00 :5 CA n D 0 0- t 0) CID o i' n oN~ 0) -A N y° A O o O- a, :z D'u+ M, N, N M O Q y O O~ ^ O D> O O prl O O- 1 O ro i In o o n n d O- y 0 0-- 0 ro ? `0 L n n o n N cNO c~D 4- ck) 0. 0) O p' 0 ~ Ti i (ID 0 O D r+ ~ m n G O o, ro O _ ,6 ° i CD S O, ro O- tY an CID N O 00 ro Q" O '6 4- CD C Q 3 et ro ev u 0) C, 0 o r? O- ~ w G d p„ co CD D> P. p 6 !t (ID Cl- CID cr C'. ro ~ o- -a o G v+ ro ro ro b ro v+ T tv~ Y or' s O o+ ro 01, - (ID O -s 6 G UQ m N d~ Q n p W (ID O ro Q n u ro ts- CpD O C Ida ii- (ID rr r+ p ^ Z O O - m r+ 4 O~ t3- rr 0 0), S tp 0) et 0 0) Cl 4. CD 0. r-11' S ro OQ W i 'LA c~D x G N o~ ro ro -6 ~ cn O O' O e. ro O Lp O 911 00 v al Lp W n v as D cn cn Ln s r m m d rD cu :3 m S O M rD r+ v rD a W O CL m , O O ?r r r m rD rrDD o o o n n N S Q* rD 0 rr r+ m rD rD ° A o Q 3 fD n N m '•'r m a- n O O O rD '6 'a - UU N O _ rD N O un Uo -a = = n n -a o rD < < m a rD "a O O (D n Q.. rD rD -O -6 m rD rD N a_ a_ M r+ N M Oo O r L^ rD N 0 rD D rr rD (D a) 1 O M y, O O 5 'o w 3 N a) a) fi< n' a N O S y O n 00 N N' Q M O oo 0 m rD S 0 w C _ Q rr o! r+ r+ cJ N o a0i O f7 0'4 ~ CA m N (D 3 a" cl 3 O S T 1+ N 7 O N n (p Q- O M N G ~I S O < i O n rr O w S O r( v d cD O °O m 0 rr orq c -a Lnn O o N N G - D 3 1+ X- F; Ln O rD p°D 0 fD s O S rD r+ N N 7 Q D C a.. N -0 O < C Q n Q -0 C v O o Q O O N N 0 -0 y i0i+ r r N 0 a O G Q ?r a = n -00 3 n rD °1 N -a O O < O O W rD n N+ -a O S rD O -G O = m m Q N Q' r r (D n SCL h -S y n 3_ tZ C) 0 z N 0 N h rD 3 O a) in O Q v7ri _ m < O (D W C 3 O N S -a N N 0 3 -0 0 Q O M :3 r+ rD -6 n rrDD Q.. O 0 0 (D ' * m W x C7 00 (.D S N O s al O < O rD (nD O N S(D C -0 G N fD N (1 N r•+ O Q O :3 Q. 3 r0-h a; 7 a) rD 0 (D CD- FT (D O Qq O Q? cn O CU Q N G S rD -cu 1 O CL rD Q O C (D 3 0 O rD -a ~ N O S n s rt o fl+ N (D O (:i~' C Q rj rr < rD ai G Z fD a- -a N S a" W o :3 O rD aQ Q O r+ fi O rD (D ui -a D D D D D D D m CU 3 w rD o0 ou o~ o~ Una c) v cD a ° O m a ao " as " M C O M rrDD T m m m m m(D Q ° N O 0- CL CL a- a- o cu rD D = ao o rD pq O rnr Q' 0 O r0r S+ i^ O aJ O lD On O O Ln S -s O w O N w m c rD rD CL) z m = N a) Q. a Dv c + x :3 O O Q (D - G -.i, Q M rD rr rr rD o oo v 1 N al S O O_ r+ -1 " :3 fD O CD rD rD O r r ~ y (D a) rr 3 Q n o m (D v rD s p< c N O rD rF a- v S CCD x' m N' a c r+ 3 M o Q N r+ S N o 0 w o * rr r+ rD G -a O o v rD C N N a~j S fi D o O ~ O 7 S (SD -i W n f1 rD rD -s Q ~ r0 7 = ~ O rD O D Un 0 rD N Q- S fD CU S a) rD W -i a7 rr a) ~ O rD O 7r Q m rD fl (SD rD :3 O O C S r+ Q rD