Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutC_820_TREE-2019-00057 Aaron Anderson From: SOTC <info@sotreecare.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 28, 2019 2:21 PM To: Aaron Anderson Subject: 820 C St Mr Anderson, regarding our telephone conversation this morning: 1 recommend removal of the silver maple (Ater saccharinum) in the right of way due to the amount and size of wood that will need to be cut out. The size of this wound will cause major decay and health decline in this tree, very possibly whole tree failure. Also, being under power lines, this tree has a much too large potential stature for this site. Please feel free to contact me if you have any further questions Willie Gingg Southern Oregon Tree Care, Llc Y.S.A. Board Certified Master Arborist i STREET TREE REMOVAL PERMIT Planning Division C [ T Y Q F 51 Winburn Way, Ashland OR 97520 ,ASHLAND 541-488-5305 Fax 541-488-6006 A tree that is located in any public street right-of-way or other public property may not be removed until a Street Tree Removal Permit has been submitted according to the Application Submission Requirements, below, and reviewed and approved by the City of Ashland. An application for street tree removal must demonstrate that the tree is an emergency, hazard, or dead tree as outlined below in the Application Submission Requirements, Application Submission Requirements. An application for a street tree removal permit shall include all of the following information. 1. Application Form and Fee. The application must include the information requested on the Street Tree Removal Permit form provided by the City of Ashland and the permit application fee. Only those property owners of a lot adjoining the street tree location or homeowners' associations responsible for street trees in their development or subdivision may apply to remove an adjoining street tree. If a tree is located in front of more than one property, each property owner or homeowners' association official must sign the Street Tree Removal Permit form, 1 Site Plan. F; site plan of the property drawn to scale containing the following information. The scale of the site plan must be at least one inch equals 50 feet or larger. a. North arrow and scale. b, Property boundaries including dimensions of all lot lines and driveway locations. c. Location and width of all public streets, planting strips, and sidewalks adjoining the site, d. Size, species, and location of the tree(s) proposed to be removed. 3. YVritt;M Statement. A written statement explaining how the proposed street tree removal satisfies one of the following approval criteria. T{ke Community Development director may require additional information to demonstrate that the proposed removal satisfies one of the following approval criteria Including; 1) a written statement to be prepared by an arborist licensed by the State of Oregon Landscape Contractors Board of Construction Contractors Board and certified by the International Society of Arboriculture or American Society of Consulting Arborists; and 2) an International Society of Arboriculture (ISA) Basic Tree Risk Assessment Form to be completed by an arborist. Street Tree Removal Approval Criteria a) Emergency Tree Removal. The tree presents an immediate danger of collapse and represents a clear and present hazard to persons or property. immediate danger of collapse is defined as a tree that may already be leaning, with the surrounding soil heaving, and/or there is a significant likelihood that the tree will topple or otherwise fail and cause damage before a tree removal permit could be obtained through the non-emergency process, b) Hazard Tree Removal. The tree presents a clear public safety hazard (i.e., likely to fall and injure persons or property) or a foreseeable danger of property damage to an existing structure or facility, and such hazard or danger cannot reasonably be alleviated by treatment, relocation, or prUriirig. A hazard tree is a tree that is physically damaged to the degree that it is clear the tree is likely to fall and injure persons or property. A hazard tree may also include a tree that is located within a public right-of-way and is causing damage to existing public or private facilities or services and such facilities or services; cannot be relocated. c) Dead Tree. The tree is dead. A dead tree is lifeless. Such evidence of lifelessness may include unseasonable lack of foliage, brittle dry branches, or lack of any growth during the growing season. Replacement and Stump Removal. Applicants for approved Street Tree Removal Permits are required to remove any stumps and replace the tree. Stump removal and replacements for approved street tree removals shall meet the following requirements. 1. Any street tree removed shall be removed at ground level or lower. If a tree is removed below ground level, the surface must be restored to finiso grade and any regrowth which occurs shad be promptly removed. 2. All street trees shall be an appropriate species selected from and planted according to the City of Ashland Recommended Street Tree List. 1 The minimum size for a replacement tree is eight feet in height or one inch in caliper measured at 12 inches above the root crown, 4. Applicants for a Street Tree Removal Permit may be required to replace the tree or trees being removed with a tree or trees of comparable value. 5. If a sf:reet tree is determined to be dead or dying, their the replacement creed be no larger than the min irniize size described above. Type of Tree(s) 1e ^ t ~ r Approximate Diameter at breast height Height Canopy Location of Tree Reason for Request ~Y Are there underground utility lines andlor overhead power lines present? V'`..' If yes, please list which lines are present NQ Is there sidewalk damage? If yes, has a Public Works permit been issued? t~ s OVER 1101 C:Wsers%1v=sa\CLnktopl$Treet Tree Removal Pa mit_Revised 29I6.doc ~oP'4? 02 Pastna~"7?u:~ad ?Cnowa~ aas j 1au751do1'ISa~esc~n~s2as71.~ a}gyp aanleubiS aaftugq BuluuBI&JOPWId 4uawdolan0d Ajiunuatuoo S3,1 ❑ ONrE ~payl}ou.uaaq sey ao}ea}slulwpy All 0 ay} sey S3~ ❑ OIL aaa}ead6 ao y q p „g~ aaa} ay} si JIM ddy}osuoi}IpuoO paluap , suoi}tpuo y}Im. panoaddV : panoaddy -(auo ajoilo) Aga~q sI }Iwaad. :IVOISI030 JAMS a}a~ (paiinbad) ain}au6IS s,aaunn0 >iiaftd unod6 a~!; uo Aa;eooj J~ Apedord we s~ua(ia_ ~oidtur,ro 'sain oni s 'saarJ 1Ie Je A y; (E daypnl pue.e;enbape ade uor;eo?jdde sty; uq pau?e;uoo uor;ewdopr ay;;ey; fZ ;sanbad sry; poddns o; aouaprna jen;oe};uarops paonpo)d l;ey; (j :ysgge;sa o; atu uo aq jljm uepdnq ay; 'pa;sa;uoo ~j;uanbasgns sr;sanbar sry; pr eq; pue;sdapun dayun;; ';oaddoa pus and; 's;oadsad lie uj ade uo?;egrjdde sjy; ur paure;uoo uoo;ewdo;ur pue s;wawa;e;s ay;;ey; Appeo ,Sgaday j dauMo 4pedodd e se aw o; saouanbasuoo sp pue uor;eoZydde a;ajdwoo ay; poopepun pue paad aney j ';senbad sry; u; panjonur Apadodd ay; jo daumo sy diZ CIO ssadppv ~ieW-3 auoyd aweN ai}?1 diZ - 40 ssadppV awep~~'' al}!1 auoyd ~dp 213H10 IIH~0--JV 3dVOSQNVI 1S 8NV dIZ 40 ssaippy FAI-3 auoyd awl~-N Palmas aaa} • •a IVAO1N3N 33b1 3H1 9NIIM80d2I3d -1VN0ISS3d0md dIZ 40 ssaippy i1eW-3 auoyd aweN _ dIZ11~ 40 s ssaippv . r i1eA Z. Z I ® 71I auoyd awe N N3NM0 AIN3d08d uoI}eu6isa0 ueld dwoo 6UIU07 (s)}o7 Xi i I 6C 'ON deA s,jossassy r 1 ~ f° % M . J' ~ - ssadppy }aaa}g VIS~ ,WOd02Id AO N0I1dINDS30 CONDITIONS OF APPROVALTREE2019-00057 in accordance with Ashland Municipal Code (AMC) 18.16, applicants for approved Street Tree Removal Permits are required to remove any stumps and replace the tree. Stump removal and replacements for approved street tree removals shall meet the following requirements. 1. Any street tree removed shall be removed at ground level or lower. If a tree is removed below ground level, the surface must be restored to finish grade and any regrowth which occurs shall be promptly removed. 2. The tree must be replaced and the minimum size for a replacement tree is eight feet in height or one inch in caliper measured at 12 inches above the root crown. 3. All street trees shall be an appropriate species selected from and planted according to the City of Ashland Recommended Street Tree List. 4. That the applicant shall remove the sidewalk and have a professional arborist examine the underlying root structure. Should the arborist conclude that if the trees health would be compromised or become structurally unstable due to root removal then they are authorized to remove the tree. 5. The arborist shall report the results and disposition of the tree to the planning department- 1W a STREET TREE REMOVAL PERMIT Planning Division 51 Winburn. Way, Ashland OR 9'7520 c' F O F ASHLAND 541-488-5305 Fax 541-488-6006 A tree that is located in any public street right-of-way or other public property may not be removed until a Street Tree Romov9.Permit=;has been. submitted according to the Application Submission Requirements, below, and reviewed and approved by the City of Ashland. An application for street tree removal must demonstrate that the tree is an emergency, hazard, or dead tree as outlined below in the Application Submission Requirements. Application Submission Requirements. An application for a street tree removal permit small include all of the following information, 1. Application Form an¢ Fee. The application must include the information requested cn the Street Tree Removal Permit form provided by the City of Ashland and the permit application fee. Only those property owners of a lot adjoining the street tree location or homeowners' associations responsible for street trees in their development or subdivision may apply to remove an adjoining street tree. If a tree is located in front of more than one property, each property owner or homeowners' association official must sign the Street Tree Removal Permit form, 2. Site Plan. Fi site plan of the property drawn to scale containing the following information. The scale of the site plan must be at least one inch equals 50 feet qr larger. a. North arrow and scale. b. Property boundaries including dimensions of all lot lines and driveway locations, c. Location and width of all public streets, planting strips, and sidewalks adjoining the site. d. Size, species, and location of the tree(s) proposed to be removed. 3. Jritt'~n Statement. A written statement explaining how the proposed street tree removal satisfies one of the following approval criteria. T e Community Development director may require additional information to demonstrate that the proposed removal satisfies one of the following approval criteria including: 1) a written statement to be prepared by an arborist licensed by the State of Oregon Landscape Contractors Board of Construction Contractors Board and certified by the International Society of Arboriculture or American Society of ConsdIting Arborists; and 2) an International Society of Arboriculture (ESA) Basic Tree Risk Assessment Form to be completed by an arborist. Street Tree Removal Approval Criteria a) Emergency Tree Removal. The tree presents an immediate danger of collapse and represents a clear and present hazard to persons or property. Immediate danger of collapse is defined as a tree that may already be leaning, with the surrounding soil heaving, and/or there is a significant likelihood that the tree will topple or otherwise fail and cause damage before a tree removal permit could be obtained through the non-emergency process. b) Hazard Tree Rdmoval. The tree presents a clear public safety hazard (i.e., likely to fall and injure persons or property) or a feresepable danger of property damage to an existing structure or facility, and such hazard or danger cannot reasonably be alleviated by treatment, relocation, or prbning, A hazard tree is a tree that is physically damaged to the degree that it is clear the tree is likely to fall and injure persons or property. A hazard tree may also inclyde a tree that is located within a public right-of-way and is causing damage to existing public, or private facilities or services and such facilities or services cannot be relocated. c) Dead Tree. The tree is dead. A dead tree is lifeless. Such evidence of lifelessness may include unseasonable lack of foliage, brittle dry branches, or lack of any growth during the growing season. Replacement and Stump Removal. Applicants for approved Street Tree Removal Permits are required to remove any stumps and replace the tree. Stump removal and replacements for approved street tree removals shall meet the following requirements. 1. Any street tree removed shall be removed at ground level or lower. If a tree is removed below ground level, the surface must be restored to finish grade and any regrowth which occurs shall be promptly removed. 2. All street tree's shall be an appropriate species selected from and planted according to the City of Ashland Recommended Street Tree List. 3. The minimum size for a replacement tree is eight feet in height or one inch in caliper measured at 12 inches above the root crown. 4. Applicants for a Street Tree Removal Permit may be required to replace the tree or trees being removed with a tree or trees of comparable value. 5. If a street tree is determined to be-dcM or dying, then the replaceme,t need be no darger than the minimize size described above. l Type of Tree(s) iR 1 ~ t Approximate Diameter at breast height Height ( Canopy Location of Tree Reason for Request t ~ t O~AA -k Are there underground utility lines and/or overhead power lines present? If yes, please list which lines are present tQ L Is there sidewalk damage? ' A"t, If yes, has a Public Works permit been issued? OVER 1/ - C:1U5crs11ucnsa5l7esktopLStrect Trce Removal Permii„Revised 20f 6.doc ~ap'gtp~pasinag y~waad~enowagaaiyiaa~l5tdo~~jsa~t~scangs~asn~:~ • a eQ ajn}p-ublc Ja6euejN 5mueldpo}oeal0 }uawdolane0 AjlunuUPOO ~f rpl I ci} oL Jana ash _o:e,}sI~ r ,;,aid aLI ~F-~ s 1, ~J 0PJ" IJ?ae=J:3 Jo I I'F ,`d6 ;-DP j aL; SI 16V~.GJaG , i SUOI:IJuo!~.. Lc SL I,I L li o/uJ~ W ~ oP,GaGd' I•~uo J ~.A a1a s1 ILUJa a J d I u y d :NOIS1020 JJVIS i a~e0 (paJ!nboJ) ain}eu6IS s,jeumo 4adoad u a eao S~adord ale s i9A'QidLv.tjolsomonrs 'seesd e !e •punarb ay; o p ; ! ! ~ ~ ~ 1! Ul (E jogyn} pue 'alanbape we uol;eorldde sigl ui paure;uoo uo?;ew.roAi aq; ley; (e ';sanboj sry;,uoddns o; aauaprna fen;oej;ua? tys peonpold f;ey; (k :ysllgplse o; atu uo a4l1!M ueprnq a y; 'pa;seluoo Alluanbasgns s! ;sanba)su7; j! ley; puepfapun ragpn; l )oa)Joa pue aril 's;aadsal !!e ui are uor;eolldde sry; ur paure;uoo uol;ewlo;ui pue s;wawa;e;s au;;gq; /(ppao Sgaraq l •lauMO radold e se aw of saouanbasudo sp pue u1 ' eolldds a;aldwoo ay; poolsrapun pue peal aneq l ';sanbar siq} uq panronur radord ay;;o saumo sy d!Z ssaJPPV IieW-3 auoyd aweN aWi diz 40 0- / ssaippv yep- auoyd aw~('j~ al~!1 NSHI0 10311H0N'd 3dV0SONv .LsiNos fd d€Z X10 ssaippv HEN-3 auoyd aweN aolnJes 094 ..a It/AOVg38 332I13H.L 0NIWN0d283d IMISS3d02Id di 40 ss@jppv IIeIN 3 auoyd aweN d!Z'ly Sl0 z ssaJppy -QQi> Dy w IiM- OF) f 7,"~ auoyd j f aweN NEINM0 AiN3dONd uo!;eu61sa0 veld dwo0 6uluoz (s)m Ai 3 ~ 6E 'ON de.n,s,ioss@ssv L~ssaJPPb';aaJlS r ,kiU3d0Nd JO NOUdIKS30 City of Ashland Community Development Department PERMIT NUMBER Way TREE-2019-00057 Ashland, OR 97520 Apply Date: 4!2!2019 Telephon51e: 541Winburn-488-5305 M Inspection Line: 541-552-2080 Plan Type: Tree Removal Work Class: Tree Removal Permit Review Ma &.Tax Lot Property Address 391 E09AC9700 820 C St Owner Information Applicant Infornnatior Owner: John Sanders Applicant: All Concrete Owner 820 C St Applicant Address: Ashland, OR 97520 Address: Phone: - Phone: (5441) 261-8400 Project description Remove street Tree Fees Fee Description: Amount: Tree RemovalNerifioat] on Fee {Type l} $30.00 Applicant: Bate: Total' Fees $30.00 Basic Tree Risk Assessme fi orm Client Al g-L Date . Tme.' / Address/Tree location L Tree n Sheet of Tree species 1®1 14 dbh Height ELO Crown spread dia. J Assessor(s) Time frame Tools used Target Assessment Target zone Occupancy d s rate $ ° c M1 I-rare c c x' X 2-occasonal Z' L r 'target description Q m _ ~ m u 7 w u ut 3-frequest a-mn.nt d 2 3 4 Site Factors History of failures Topography F14slope❑ % Aspect Site changes None ❑ Grade change❑ Site clearing❑ Changed soil hydrolo Root cuts ❑ Describe Soil conditions Limited volume ❑ Saturated ❑ Shallow ❑ Compacted ❑ Pavement over roots ifiAL1% Describe fj ~o x; 1Z Prevailing wind direction Afcornmon weather Strong wind 1% & Snoy<3 Heavy ra Describe Tree Health and Species Profile Vigor Low 12 Normal High O Foliage None (seasonal} None (dead) ❑ Normal % Chlorotic % Necrotic % Pests Abiotic Speciesfailure profile BranchesO Trunk❑ Roots❑ Describe C 1 ► f ~~f~. '"F^? • Load Factors Windexposure Protected❑ Partial❑ Full' windfunneling❑ Relative crown size Smal]❑ MediumLarge❑ Crown density 5parse© Normal Dense❑ Interior branches Few❑ NormalDense© Vines/Mistletoe/Moss ❑ Recent or planned change in load faciors Tree Defects and Conditions Affecting the;l.ikelihood.of Failure Crown and Branches - Unbalanced crown ❑ LCR % Cracks ❑ Lightning damage ❑ Dead twigs/branches ❑ _%overall Max. dia. Codominant ❑ Included bark ❑ Broken/Hangers Number Max. dia. Weak attachments ❑ Cavity/Nest hole %circ. Over-extended branches ❑ Pruning history Previous branch failures ❑ Similar branches present Crown cleaned ❑ Thinned ❑ Raised ❑ Dead/Missing bark 13 Cankers/Galls/Burls ❑ Sapwood damage/decay ❑ Reduced ❑ Topped ❑ Lion-tailed ❑ Conks ❑ Heartwood decay ❑ Flush cuts ❑ Other Response growth Main concern(s) Load on defect N/A ❑ Minor ❑ Moderate O Significant El Likelihood of failure improbable 13 Possible ❑ Probable ❑ Imminent ❑ -Trunk- - Roots and Root Collar - Dead/Missing bark ❑ Abnormal bark texture/color ❑ Collar buried/Not visible ❑ Depth Stem girdling ❑ Codominantstems ❑ included bark ❑ Cracks ❑ Dead ❑ Decay ❑ Conks/Mushrooms ❑ Sapwood damage/decay ❑ Cankers/Galls/Burls❑ Sap ooze ❑ ooze ❑ Cavity ❑ %circ. Lightning damage❑ Heartwood decay ❑ Conks/Mushrooms ❑ Cracks O Cut/Damaged roots ❑ Distance from trunk Cavity/Nest hole %circ. Depth Poor taper ❑ Root plate lifting ❑ Soil weakness ❑ Lean ° Corrected? Response growth Response growth Main concern(s) Main concem(s a l m, ~ i Load on defect N/A O Minor E] Moderate D Significant O Load on defect N/A 0 Minor O Moderate[] Significant O Likelihood of failure ALikelihood of failure Improbable❑ Possible ❑ Probable ❑ Imminent ❑ Improbable ❑ Possible ❑ Probable ❑ Imminent ❑ Page I of 2 Z }o Z 51 Di - sisuogn (-Oy d.L) PaS?IEnt7 zuamssassy Ism easy (q asn ao; papuaaa! s pue (VSI) aml mnogsy 3o daapog jzuoxz sal~T aqZ ~q Paanpoxd sen>>aagssxzp 5 tII aq!jasap paunq jelloo lood[] sau!n❑ ssaooy❑ Agrl!q!srn❑ awON❑ suo4e41w!i uo!padsu[ uosea!!/adAl-saA❑ ONE] papaau;uawssasse paouenpy AJI?Urwrla-Id ❑ leuH ❑ elea lenJaju! uo.45adsui papuauiwooaU ❑ awaJlx3 ` .g2IH ❑ ale~apolAJ ❑ Ma! 4s!a [enp!saa lleaanp ❑ -V ❑ E ❑ Z ❑ T A}uo!jd )ljom p awaalx3 n~LI211-1 ❑ aleJapOW ❑ Mod 2u!4e.J )[S!J aa,; Ileaano )ls!a lenp!s;)U >[s!a lenp!saa Isp [enp!saU .1!l Ns!a lenp!salj suo!4do uop,e& ~y ra ~ suoy.d!l3sJp sun~eue[dxa a;oil MOS.:...., MOI MO" AA01-; Alaivn aleaapolnl alelapov!: mol Ma-l . ARM leymawoS `JON gOIH 01H alwapovq Mo-! Alan awaaxI 421!i alelapovq MOI AlaNg JUan L aou! ~ ~ i ~ ' € ~ a3ana lue~ iu3F ' ✓ i S S W a19!8!I2aN ~edwl ~8 ajnl!e~ I ainl!e:l;o saouan.basuo:) 39 Poo Nl )HI 'r WMEw $upej >ls% zxuTnw 4 RQ i Amilun Alaililun Alanuft Alamun algegoldwl {v • ; ~ ~ 1., Alai!l le!{mawog - /,lamuR ,4lanun ,4lal!lup' a[q!ssod.. Ala4ll Ala)m IEgMawos tila nun Ala>l!lurl algego.id Aa>i!l Ia!I le4MawoS /,I;3 rIuR 4uau!ww[ Ala~!l 1 haaA E I y$!W wn!pajN M0.1 nmol AJaA aanpei;o I { ;a2aej.Su!loedwl;o poo4!10~!1 poo4!la?I!l: Z wJI' u pooq!la>lrl'INI-w U 17 0001010 Z) 000 P01000101 0 D E Q 001010 oo rDQ 0000000 1OK-D"100003. 0 ® o 00 z oo 0000 DOOOOOD Q® 30001001 o 1000000 0 (zxpleW m 'n g z g y c x ¢ a a y uopajoid uaaouoo ;o ved aaji n ~ o m 3 0 w d m o wnj;7 c -c m s a 1 3 m o Za2je,L St1041pLL0:) a. E: ID E zt. m c 3 m m v m Suliea m ~ ~ M cr ~ w ro ~ ai5!a m {Z xuyy usoyl r saouanbasuo-_~ vedwlTaanl!e3 laedwl aanl!e 3 z m povy!la~l!~ u04ez!ao2a4e:. Is!}l Risk Categorization Likelihood a Failure & Impact Consequences c u 0 Failure Impact (from Matrix 1) Risk E m W rating Conditions H Target part - e o E a m =aa c y (from u° Tree part of concern Q ti ~ protection - ~ a` ~ j ~ ~ _ ~ c°n 9 Z ~ n vi matrix 2) 1 0 0 000010000CC000 0000100,00 00 000 2 00,0000100C000000 0000000000,000010 0000 0 00 010 0 0 3 0000 000 0' 00 0 0®0 0 0 0 X00 4 0 000 0 .0 0 Matrix 1. Likelihood matroc Likelihood 7kellh6od of Impacting Target I I l of Failure velY to+u Low Medium High I l Imminent Ln' kely Somewhat likely Likely Ven; I kel+; Probable Ln kely Unl ke 1 Sorr.e^> hat likely Jkeh., ( ~rti l / Possible L'n] k ly Unl k :v Ur.l . y Somewhat kke[y Cmprpbable Unlikely Ur,li_.v Unlikely I ( I ~I uJb z7. Risk rating matrix. Maur ,LikelihoodIof consequences of Failure Failure & Impact Neg' h .ible Minor Significant Severe r k tree? - I L~ Il€, 4 Very likely Low P.lcderzte H.;, g. Likely Low Moderate P.1gh: High' North Somewhatlikely Lo Low rvToderate rvlod rate r Unlikely, Low Lo•.+; Lo,^; Lo y scriptions r-e Note explanations, CIP t 00/1A t a Mitigation options Residual risk Residual risk Residual risk Residual risk Overall tree risk rating Low ❑ Moderate ❑ High`E l Extreme ❑ Work priority 1 ❑ 2 ❑ 3 ❑ 4 Overall residual risk Low El moderate O High"EL Extreme D Recommended inspection interval Data ❑ Final ❑ Preliminary Advanced assessment needed ❑No ❑Yes-Type/Reason Inspection limitations ❑None ❑Visibility ❑Access ❑Vines ❑Rcat collar buried Describe 'Ms datasbeet was produced by the International Society of Arboriculture GSA) and is intended for use by Tree Risk Assessment Qualified (i RAQ) arborists - 20!3 Page 2 of 2 ASHLAND TREE COMMISSION PLANNING APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENT SHEET May 9, 2019 PLANNING ACTION: TREE-2019-00057 SUBJECT PROPERTY: 820 C Street OWNERSIAPPLICANTS: John Sanders/All Concrete & Hooper Springs DESCRIPTION: A request for a Street Tree Removal Permit to remove one approximately 15-inch diameter Acer/ Maple tree at 820 C St. The application notes that this street tree is lifting and damaging the sidewalk. The concrete has previously been ground down approximately four years ago. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN DESIGNATION: Low Density, Multi-Family Residential; ZONING: R-2; ASSESSOR'S MAP: 39 1 E 09AC; TAX LOT: 9700 Following a presentation by staff there was extensive deliberations due to the uncertainty that the sidewalk could be replaced without putting the health of the tree at risk. The Tree Commission moved to approve the application subject to the following: 1. That the applicant shall remove the sidewalk and have a professional arborist examine the underlying root structure. Should the arborist conclude that if the trees health would be compromised or become structurally unstable due to root removal then they are authorized to remove the tree. 2. The arborist shall report the results and disposition of the tree to the planning department. Department of Community Development Tel: 541.488-5350 C I T Y OF 51 Winbum Way Fax: 541-552-2050 Ashland, Oregon 97520 TTY: 800-735-2900 www.ashland.or.us ~.r~,. rl alJ. I J r x~ ~ I ly 'r~ fly. r,~Gh rIK" ~sy j~a~~} { 1 -L 1 _ i - y 1'~J~^ r Pdy y~~` 'y J. a I p, o ~ tea: - _ _ + - 'I~ '?yam. 'a_ ~u~~T"4-` ~ _ _ - _ _ d~ ~~~+~T--~'1~~*'r°A h 'lr 1~P..• _ _ + rn a* fi h i m I _ n . , . eel _ -t 4 _ ~ ~n~ _ ~.a . N _ r ' ~X573 -H'- - _ - LT i - r , M1y a v II _ t - _ - ~'Pk y A ry~~ E+ 7, a t 4, 1 , m tic mac.-.-- ~ .~..ac _ ;,+_I ~ _:~dn. _ 5 '..r~: W. _;KN •i~13~~ ~4 - ~ ~ u~: - r.. Je . ,f +r,~,~ 23 ~ :Yg x r 9 _ ~$,i 1 c tiI" 11 r,~g!Yr . yr+' S •f~A`'1Y.. mlT+. s4T'MEN d".,Fs k, t,,F4,ffra' f s , r• ° q" .y ~7 'V eat4 Y` ,w fof`~'' ode, ulj y • sv~4 S ,IY ~,r Y tr ..y ...r... ..n :iA .v ~ ..g E... ..fr. '-p. r. '.•].IP .~?T~s;. ::'Q~Y .,_ir :.l .7 T......~y~~~~~:~' '~::Y'.. . ?'9. ,..,v...T. .....,,1Nk. ~ . .025 7 , nn . s~'r C iI r.},yh~ G 'or>~uy I rta k '~1. a A"♦~d N~ r :ilk ;'r to R . tF~t~ # a a t r I4 rp•p r k(': r ^al , a' v -c .l . hnn ~r r , r, ~FE At ■ f y~x~,zr~`~ J 1'J';ys. w a;r a ~fq, w '~a°.M..4r 3i;la'~~.~ )I filE.. ' 1' err. i .r •I:al} ~'r ,Itt nt' _ F' t, 1 -nt ~ 1 79 ti- w: n•r~~s a< ~ ~ ' ~ r , , a~~r.~~ f'~ ~x ~ I ~ ~IL. r .I I,: a. .r rk, 1 E a 1 }p s F~ :1 } _ At(k. J{W1 rk r . I y}N. ?syi ~~_o,}PMt@ rdy'i•~. i 14 . M f x• iG±rt71 v>~•➢.,"•~ il4r1O° ag. 4.1 A"'li1 e s iEY Y( I B S " } r I ~ std ~ ~ it sr}•~ ~ . ':r ")~y~„j;'~'~'.,rfa 1Er g: .,~eu8: n,,n,x,•: i1 tl a titi9~" ,era Y I`. •6~ ~ pl Yr ,bRyi - ~ ,It. Y' r y~ M F S 5 ap,1 r Er f y`r~ ' r K f 1 1 r' 'j r<a t!I)fxs;a r 9r xE3' r ) r r ~7 1 7 r h a .s: . is ~.'_~r.... li ..c r .....t.. !,...1. iii".'.,..: ~ i FEW - ~<.a'r Lo~ r f € 1 I I I` + . r...: Fa~:.. 1. ':~I~r ~ ho- i'~~!': - MD "R (t :.7 9 ~ 41i r R'rw,'i v y(Fr k rkih t IH I I i I f } ~ ~ ~`~rr-~ +Fr c I ~~y~Y.'~f r. ' • ~ T¢~``} ~'N~i~4 wI ..'~f' ~~r~ ~ YYfi J~li.i 1~y1~'• 4 Y~nf { d ~,ar•..~.~:~rr ~ a r ~ { ::'~r '~'+sf~2~.. Afrj~~•Frrl:.1 ~yr.,.~~~•:~i~~~~i~"~`~ ~ I.1•?`.k ~ R~ ~Trs l , ~ rv~aEN t+~YI, Ar, },R sl 1k ~V~ 7, y ypl 1 y J f, •i n r ii ~ L 14 i } r` I r' '1 r q ~ ",J~' kil' • `~I Et ~ f ~YI't•~ ' rr ~,r~. ~ V 3, t r~ a,l