The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2000-04-05 Historic MIN ASHLAND HISTORIC COMMISSION Minutes April 5, 2000 CALL TO ORDER At 7:35 p.m., Chairperson Jim Lewis called the meeting to order at the Community Center. Members present were Terry Skibby, Jim Lewis, Dale Shostrom, Joan Steele, Vava Bailey, Keith Chambers, Kay Maser, Jay Leighton and Gary Foll. Also present were Associate Planner Mark Knox and Secretary Sonja Akerman. Jay Leighton was appointed by the Mayor at the April 4 City Council meeting to replace Curt Anderson. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Maser pointed out that on page 3 of the March 8, 2000 minutes in the second paragraph, manor should be changed to manner. Also on the same page in the eighth paragraph, insulted should be changed to insulated. Shostrom then moved to approve the minutes as corrected. Steele seconded the motion and it was unanimously passed. PUBLIC HEARINGS Planning Action 2000-038 Conditional Use Permit and Site Review 361 Scenic Drive James and Robynne Whitaker Shostrom declared he is the designer for this project; therefore, he sat in the audience. Knox reported the applicants are proposing to build a 576 square foot accessory residential unit above a two-car garage. The existing garage/shed is non-conforming so it will be removed and replaced with the proposed structure, which will comply with current setback requirements. Knox explained this property is a shotgun lot, which means it is located between two streets – in this case Scenic Drive and Alta Street. One parking space will be located on Scenic and one will be on Alta. The other two are provided in the garage. Knox noted Alta Street will be paved this summer. The building design is compatible with the existing house and the materials will match. Bailey commented the new building would be taller than the house. Knox, however, pointed out it will be excavated three feet. Chambers noted he had been invited to walk in the back yard with the owner and agreed it will be higher, but since the surrounding buildings are mostly two-story and vertical in nature, it will be compatible. Steele moved to recommend approval of this planning action and Foll seconded the motion. In discussing this, the Commission asked Shostrom to clarify questions on height and materials. He responded by stating the existing house is set back 25 feet from the street. It is a Craftsman style with a gable roof and is almost three stories high. The roof on the new structure will be hipped to match the house with a 7 x 12 pitch and will face back. While it will be two feet higher than the house, it will look more like one and one-half stories because the ground floor will be dug in three feet. From Alta Street, it will look like a single story. The first story will be cement stucco and the roofing material will be architectural composition shingles. Although she is not against this proposal, Bailey commented she would not want to set precedence with this approval for accessory units above garages. All members voted aye except Shostrom, who abstained. BUILDING PERMITS Permits reviewed by members of the Historic Commission and issued during the month of March follow: 713 Church Street Warren and Sheila Straus Porch Addition 131 East Main Street One World ADA Bathroom 6 Beach Avenue Diane Amick Parking/Retaining Wall 300 North Pioneer Street Erik Wallbank Interior Remodel 159 North Main Street Jon and Carmen Reinhardt Addition 63 Gresham Street Priscilla Shore Retaining Wall 91 Gresham Street Rick and Debra Barth Garage 41 North Main Street Dave Lewis Grill/Service Window 84 Alida Street Keith MacLaren Garage Remodel/Conversion 237 North First Street Ashland Community Food Store Roof Remodel 155 Strawberry Lane Ben Stott Remodel OLD BUSINESS Review Board Following is the April schedule for the Review Board, which meets every Thursday from 3:00 to at least 3:30 p.m. in the Planning Department: th April 6 Skibby, Steele, Leighton and Lewis th April 13 Skibby, Steele, Foll and Bailey th April 20 Skibby, Maser, Leighton and Foll th April 27 Skibby (birthday), Chambers, Maser and Lewis Project Assignments for Planning Actions PA# 96-086 685 “A” Street Lewis PA# 97-018 661 “B” Street Lewis PA# 98-039 Holly Street Steele and Lewis PA# 98-045 122 Church Street Bailey PA# 98-047 Between 548 & 628 North Main Street Foll PA# 99-020 525 “A” Street Lewis PA# 99-062 Van Ness Avenue Foll PA# 99-102 141 Lithia Way Shostrom PA# 99-108 340 Oak Street Shostrom PA #2000-038 361 Scenic Drive Shostrom National Historic Preservation Week rd All members were encouraged to participate in the events. Judging will take place at the May 3 meeting. Second Annual Open House The second annual open house to honor all City volunteers will be held on April 13 from 4:00-6:00 p.m. All members are encouraged to attend. NEW BUSINESS 199 Granite Street Addition Designer Milo Shubat met with the Commission in order to get feedback on an addition he is designing on the corner of Granite and Nutley Streets. After discussing different designs, the Commission’s consensus was for Shubat to try hipping the roof, reorienting the addition, getting rid of the entry so it doesn’t look like a duplex, making the breezeway several feet wider, and staying with the post-war look of the original house. The Commission appreciated Shubat’s time and effort he had put into the different designs and thanked him for coming to the meeting. Ashland Downtown Walking Tour Leighton informed the Commission SOHS would be reprinting the Ashland Downtown Walking Tour this fall. She asked that the members let her know of any corrections that need to be made. ADJOURNMENT It was the unanimous decision of the Commission to adjourn the meeting at 9:31 p.m. Ashland Historic Commission Minutes April 5, 2000 2