HomeMy WebLinkAbout07 19 17 DRAFT Criteria for Selection of City Hall Replacement ASDevelopment of Criteria for Selection of City Hall Replacement Recommendation
Alternatives The list below represents alternatives that remain tenable as of 7/12/17. Some alternatives previously discussed, including the railroad property and the Elks property, have been removed from the list, as information relating to property acquisition is not available. Alternative Cost Estimate Timeline (months)
• Seismic Retrofit on Existing City Hall* $ 6.5 M unknown
• ComDev: Expand & Consolidate $ 9.5 M 11
• Right-Size City Hall + Keep ComDev $ 8.5 M 16
• Right-Size/Keep Stucco City Hall + Keep ComDev $ 9.7 M 16
• New @ Pioneer Parking & 50 UG Stall $ 16.1 M 17
• New @ Pioneer Parking & 100 UG Stall $ 19.6 M 19
• New @ Civic Center + Consolidate** $ 12.9 M 17
• New @ Civic Center + Keep Com Dev** $ 11 M 16
• Briscoe School + Consolidate** $ 8.1 M 16
Requirements
• Must meets 2030 space needs.
• Must be seismically sound. Criteria Ideas The list below represents a compilation of criteria, including items that are important to the City and items that have been voiced by the community during public outreach events, letters, and phone calls. 1. Provides centralized services
2. Provides off-street parking for employees and customers (reduces competition for existing public
stalls)
3. Potential to increase public parking (space is available to provide additional public stalls)
4. Retains downtown presence
5. Preserves historic façade
6. Outside Hosler Dam inundation zone
7. Built to LEED standards
8. Construction timeline
* Initial study conducted by Miller Engineering (Portland). Occurred prior to the Feasibility Study.
**Alternatives developed by City after ORW completed Feasibility Study. Costs and timelines were
estimated by staff, based on construction assumptions used in the Feasibility Study
COA050044