HomeMy WebLinkAboutBrower Newspaper ArticlesThe mystery letter
Ashland Daily Tidings/DENISE
Ashland City Recorder Barbara Christensen retrieves the letter and locks up the city document vault Tue,,
Century-old message to be unveiled
By Myles Murphy
Ash]and Daily Tidings
Ashland City Recorder Barbara
Christensen has waited six long
years to open a letter that has been
sealed for a centur~
"I found a number of interesting
documents when I was doing an in-
ventory of the city document vault.
This was by far the most intrigu-
The letter is in a plain, un-
opened, undamaged and barely
wrinkled envelope. Typed on the
front is the name of Dn M.D. Brow-
er and a request that the envelope
not be opened until Jan. 1, 2001.
The doctor's name was Marcus
David Brower,
who practiced
in Ashland in
the late 19th
century and
the early 20th
centur~
Christensen
will open the
letter, with lit-
he fanfare, Brower
Tuesday, Jan. 2
at her office in City Hall on the
Plaza, 20 E. Main Street.
"The most interesting thing
about the story is that a small letter
is over a hundred years old and
that people have honored the re-
quest not to open it," said Ashland
historian Kay Atwood.
The letter was found among Oth-
er documents dated around 1910,
but with no date on the letter. Its ex-
act age is unknown.
Brower was born in 1858. He re-
ceived a medical degree from
Willamette UnivereiW in 1888 and
started practice in Ashland in 1893.
He lived and practiced in Ashland
for the rest of his life.
Brower treated typical maladies
of the day, and reported in Septem-
ber 1928 that he had aided a patient
injured after being dragged around
by a runaway cow and a woman
who fractured her wrist while
hand-cranking a Ford. He died in
1939.
Early in his career, he focused
on the unhealthy conditions in
Ashland which spread disease.
Atwood quotes Brower on those
concerns in her 1985 book, '~kn
Honorable History: 133 Years of
The outside of the plain, manila-colOred envelope
reads: 'To be opened Jan. 1st, 2001. Deposited by D.M..
Brower M.D.LL.D. 216 Central Ave. Ashland, Oregon.'
Medical Practice in Jackson Coun-
ty, Oregon."
'~Ashland at the time of my com-
ing was a very unsanitary town,"
Atwood quoted Brower as saying.
"Diseases that were gendered and
spread by frith and poverty were
common. The following winter
there was an epidemic of scarlet
fever spread all over the town. Af-
ter it got well scattered, the Town
Council appointed me as chairman
of the health beard. The stopping
of the epidemic was some job. Nev-
ertheless, by establishing an efI~l-
cient quarantine and a campaign
for sanitation, there were no more
new foci and the epidemic was
stayed.
"When the danger was on, the
officers were very smooth and
friendly, but when the danger was
past and I presented my bill of $10
which ought to have been twice as
much, my popdlarity waned
promptly," Brower continued. "The
council demurred at the bill; I ex-
plained; it did a lot of good. Now,
the council, following the advice of
the City Attorney, whom they paid
$50 a month, allowed me $5 and
fired me off the board. LESSON: If
you hold an office in which the pub-
lic should be served, do nothing, ff
you want to get public approval."
Brower had a hard time getting
city officials to take measures
against the unsanitary conditions
in town, a frustration made worse
by the death from scarlet fever of
many Ashland children, including
his own daughter in 1894.
"He'd had some bitter expert-
ences," Atwood said.
But if these bitter experiences
colored the contents of the letter, or
ff Brower is simply wishing the
town a Happy New Year 2001, At-
wood would not hazard a guess.
But Brewer lived through some
of Ashland's most interesting
times, and could be sending city
residents a message about any
number of people or events.
Could he know why Dr. Francis
B. Swedenburg, who moved to Ash-
land in 1907, replaced Dr. Joseph
Herndon as physician in charge of
the Ashland sanitarium? Did he
have inside information on Ash-
land's f~rst physician, David Sisson,
who also became Asbland's first
murder victim (still unsolved) in
18587 Or what about the fire that
brought down the Southern Ore-
gon Hospital in 19097
What did he think of Lithia
Park, started in 1908, or the
Carnegie Library in 19127
Brower was here tbr the Spanish
influenza epidemic, which caused
the city to cancel all public meet-
ings and shut down schools and
churches in 1918. He saw the clos-
ing of the Natatorium and Chau-
tauqua shortly after World War I,
and the opening of the Lithla
Springs Hotel in 1925, and South-
ern Oregon State Normal School
in 1926, now Southern Oregon Uni-
versity
He witnessed the bitter feud be-
tween city physicians and big-
spending eccentric Jesse Wrmburn,
who bought the old Granite Street
Hospital, f~xed it up, and gave it to
the city as a gift. Winburn was ru-
mored to have offered large
amounts of money to influence city
council votes.
Winbur n also refused to stop let-
ting his cows and horses foul the
upper reaches of Ashland Creek,
the town's water supply, That was
another soutx~ of friction.
Third-generation Ashland resi-
dent R. Gene Morris, 74, who owns
Oak Street Tank & Steel, knew
Brower's second daughter Voda
Brewer (now deceased). He has lit-
tle recollection of the doctor him-
self and no idea what might be in
the letter.
"I'll be there for the opening of
the letter if I can make it," Morris
said. "I lived up the street from Vo-
da and I can vaguely remember Dr.
Brower. That's all I know about the
Brower family,"
After waiting six years to open
the letter, Christensen had a mo-
ment of worry earlier this week
when the letter went missing.
"I was so nervous," she said. "To
have something like that and lose it
would be not only d,isappeint to me,
but a loss for histow."
But the letter, safeguarded in a
desk, turned up, much to Chris-
tensen's relief.
"Now it's going in the vault and
it's going to stay there until Tues-
day,'' she said.
Historical information and photo
courtesy Kay Atwood and her books,
"Jackson County Conversations,"
1975; '~4n Honorable History," 1985;
and, ?Ashland Community Hospital:
A Century of Caring, "1996~
Missive focuses.. :,' e'
on global order,
'perpetual peace'
By Myles Murphy
The contents of a 64-year-old letter
opened at the Ashland City Hall this morn-
ing were a surprise to aU present.
The letter was written by Ashland doctor
David Brower, who lived in Ashland fi'om
1893 until his death in 1939, and experienced
many of the city's historic occasions. But in
his letter, Brower adopted a global view as
he outlined a recipe for world order.
'~t the present rate of progress Interna-
tionalism should be in full flower. It is the
hope of the writer that itmay be useful ... to
show the way out to perpetual peace on the
international highway to perpetual peace,"
Brower wrote.
"We were all a little disappointed that it
wasn't more directed at community issues
of the time," said Barbara Christensen,
Asbland's city recorder and treasure.
A small crowd had gathered for the
opening, including Ashland Mayor-elect
Alan DeBoer and Councilmen Cameron
Hanson and David Fine.
Brower penned four type-written pages
-- a cover letter and a document titled "Pr~
posed Constitution of an International
Union of States" -- on Oct. 26, 1936, bis 78th
birthday. The missive was put into the trust
of former City Recorder James Adams at
the time, and has been kept by seven city
recorders, includtug Christensen. Brower
asked that the letter be opened Jan. 1, 2001,
and Christensen chose to open it today, the
first day that city offices were open.
City officials have been aware of the let-
ter since it was discovered buried in the city
document vault six years ago by Cl~ris-
tensen.
"I was hoping he'd make a prediction
about Ashland's future history," DeBoer
said.
Though the letter was interesting, said
Hanson, '~ confession or something would
have been great."
In the letter, Brower carefully laid out his
ideas on internationalism and a "Uulon of
States" that would span the globe and have
Bethlehem as a world capital.
His constitution was composed of pre-
amble and seven articles which spelled out
his vision of government in the future.
Brower described the conditions of mem-
bership in the union, a representative form
of government, and how the state would in-
teract with industry and mete out justice.
He advocated f~ee speech, press, and as-
sembly. Brower also called for non-violent
police actions.
"Except with the violently insane, non-
violence shall always be used," he wrote.
Fine, a history teacher for 15 years, said
he was not too surprised at the letter, which
expressed disappointment with the falter-
lng of the post-World War I ethic of inter-
nationalism in the years leading up to
World War II.
"That's rea)Jy a typical document of the
era," he said.
Christensen said she had contacted
Brower's grandson, who lives in Cal~farula,
but he wished not to be identified.
"He was very interested in the letter and
he gave me the impression that his grandfa-
ther was philceophlcal," Christensen said.
"He was right on."
Brower was also a man of faith, and
hoped his writings would be insp~rattonal
'~ careful, critical study (of the letter)
will disclose that more would be too much
and less would be too little. It is of no avail
until adopted but when it is would create,
will lead on to what the poets have (said)
would be the Lordship of Jesus Christ, the
Fatherhood of God and the Brotherhood of
man. It is the hope of the writer the reader
will read, discuss and preserve it for future
generations to become a blessing to all The
Lord Ged will preserve men."