HomeMy WebLinkAbout2004-0805 Tree MIN
CITY OF
ASHLAND
Ashland Tree Commission
Regular Meeting
August 5, 2004
Minutes
I. Call to Order: Acting Chair January Jennings called the Ashland Tree Commission meeting to
order at 7:06 p.m. on August 5, 2004 at the Siskiyou Room in the Community
Development/Engineering Services Building at 51 Winburn Way.
Commissioners Present: Bryan Holley
Bryan Nelson
Mary Pritchard
January Jennings
Fred Stockwell
Commissioners Absent: Ted Loftus
Laurie Sager
Cate Hartzell
None
Maria Harris, Associate Planner
Donn Todt, Parks Department
Council Liaison:
Youth Liaison:
Staff Present:
II. Approval of Minutes: Holley said he believed the statement on page 2, 2nd paragraph that
says, "The Tree Commission recommended approval ofthe project with the following specific
recommendations." is inappropriate. He said it was his opinion that the Tree Commission does
not make recommendations on the decision for the total application. As a result, he asked that the
minutes be changed to say, "The Tree Commission made the following recommendations to the
Planning Commission." Pritchard noted that Prunus Bureanna should Prunus Blieriana under the
Recommendation on PA 2004-075 for 550 Mistletoe Road. Holley noted that Leland Cypress
should be Lelyand Cypress. Pritchard noted that Thuja Smarago should be Thuja Smaragd.
Holley/Nelson m/s to approve the minutes of July 8, 2004 as corrected. Voice vote: All A YES,
Motion passed.
III. Welcome Guests & Public Forum:
No guests in attendance.
IV. Public HearinQs:
A. PLANNING ACTION 2004-102 is a request for Site Review to operate a personal service
establishment involving the operation of a hot tub rental facility and related amenities (Le. showers,
sauna and steam room) at the property located at 832 A Street. In addition to two indoor
hydrotherapy tubs, the facility will operate five outdoor hot tubs within the garden area of the rear
yard. The application includes a request for a Tree Removal Permit to remove one tree.
Comprehensive Plan Designation: Employment; Zoning: E-1; Assessor's Map #: 39 1 E 09 AS; Tax
Lot: 1900.
APPLICANT: Ilene Rubenstein
A staff report was given and members of the Tree Commission asked several questions.
The clarification was made that the tree to be removed is an Almond tree. It was also
noted that there is a Holly under the existing Black Walnut in the front yard. There were
August 5, 2004 Tree Commission Minutes
Page 1 of 3
no concerns expressed regarding the Almond proposed for removal. There was a
discussion of the completeness of the plan.
There was no testimony received for or against the proposal. Jennings closed the public
hearing and the Tree Commission further discussed the proposal. The Tree Commission
made the following recommendations to the Planning Commission.
Recommendation:
Recommend continuance of planning action due to incomplete landscape plan.
Following items need to be addressed: directional arrow, landscaping plan with botanical
names, variety and sizes, tree canopies and sizes, drawn to scale, submit tree protection
plan.
Revised landscaping plan should incorporate the following suggestions.
1. Existing flowering plum in middle of lot needs tree protection.
2. Planting coverage is insufficient.
3. Root barrier for the golden bamboo
4. Otto Lyuken Laurel- not appropriate screen, is only three feet height and slow
growing. Also not shown on landscape plan.
5. Need screening on Seventh Street.
6. Use vines to soften fencing.
7. Recommend professional assistance.
The recommendation was read back to the Tree Commission by Staff, and all members
acknowledged that they were in agreement with the items as presented.
V. Action Items
A. Review Tree of the Year Timeline
There was a discussion of the upcoming Tree of the Year project and the draft
timeline. The following draft time line was agreed upon by the Commission.
1. Nominations begin Sept. 1 (City Source and on-line).
2. Nomination period closes last day of Sept.
3. Review nominations at Oct. 7 Tree Corns. meeting.
4. Ballot form printed in Ashland Daily Tidings on Oct 15.
5. Give until Oct. 31 to vote.
6. At Nov. 4 Tree Corns. meeting count ballots.
7. Announce at Nov. 16 Council meeting.
There was a discussion of the Tree of Year process being moved to fall rather than in
April last year (2003). It was discussed that the draft time line needed to be
communicated to Ann Seltzer August 17 so that it could be in the September and October
City Source newsletter.
VI. Items from Commissioners
A. New Items
There was a discussion of the landscaping and street trees recently installed for
the project at the southeast corner of Fourth and B Street. Staff reported that a
August 5, 2004 Tree Commission Minutes
Page 2 of 3
condition of approval required ground cover in the parkrows and Staff is
working on getting the project in compliance with the approval. It was
suggested that the Site Review standard requiring landscaping to be designed so
that occurs with five years.
Jennings announced that Laurie Sager and herself would be doing a Tree Walk
on October 23 at 2:00pm in Lithia Park.
Nelson asked for feedback on the checklist handed out several meetings back.
VII. Adiournment: There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 8: 11 p.m.
August 5, 2004 Tree Commission Minutes
Page 3 of 3