HomeMy WebLinkAbout2008-07-02 Historic MIN
(2/3/2009) Dana Smith - 7-2-08 Minutes.docPage 1
ASHLAND HISTORIC COMMISSION
Meeting Minutes
July 2, 2008
Community Development/Engineering Services Building – 51 Winburn Way – Siskiyou Room
CALL TO ORDER – REGULAR MEETING
At 7:02 pm, Chairman Dale Shostrom called the Historic Commission meeting to order.
Historic Commissioners Present:
Dale Shostrom, Terry Skibby, James Watkins, Allison Renwick, Keith
Swink, Alex Krach, Sam Whitford
Absent Commission Members:
Henry Baker, Tom Giordano (came in at 7:45 but recused himself)
Council Liaison:
Eric Navickas, absent
High School Liaison:
None Appointed
SOU Liaison:
None Appointed
Staff Present:
Planner: Angela Barry; Clerk: Billie Boswell
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Mr. Skibby moved to approve the minutes of the June 4, 2008 meeting. Mr. Whitford seconded the motion
and they were approved unanimously.
PUBLIC FORUM:
Cathy DeForest, 460 Sunshine Cr. talked to the Commissioners about her concerns
regarding the gun club lease and what effect the activities were having on Native American relics and the
historic Lithia Water remnants. Her concerns also included the lead toxicity and associated clean up costs.
There was also a concern that potential clean up could impact historical structures and piping for the Lithia
Waters. She asked if the Historic Commission would be willing to contact the City Council and request the
signing of the lease be delayed until an Environmental Impact study is done.
There being no one else wishing to speak, Chairman Shostrom closed the Public Forum.
PUBLIC HEARING:
Chairman Shostrom conferred with the other Commissioners and they decided to re-order the Public Hearing
agenda to hear the 165 W. Fork Street project last.
2008-00910
PLANNING ACTION:
303 & 323 Oak Street
SUBJECT PROPERTY:
Barry Peckham
APPLICANT:
DESCRIPTION: Minor land partition to divide the property at 303 Oak Street into two lots with one lot
being a flag lot. The flag lot would share a driveway with the property at 323 Oak Street. The
application includes a Variance request to reduce the required setback from 20 feet to 13 feet, a
Variance request to reduce the required parking from 5 spaces to 3 spaces, and a Variance request to
not pave the flag driveway. The applicant includes a request for a Physical and Environmental
Constraints Permit for one parking space to encroach into the area designated as Flood Plain Corridor
by the Land Use Ordinance. The application also includes a Tree Removal Permit for the removal of 3
trees, a 15-inch diameter-at-breast-height walnut tree, a 6-inch diameter-at-breast-height cherry tree,
and a 6-inch diameter-at-breast-height mimosa tree.
Ashland Historic Commission Minutes1
7/29/2008
(2/3/2009) Dana Smith - 7-2-08 Minutes.docPage 2
Chairman Shostrom read the description. Mr. Skibby asked about the location of the creek in
relationship to the project. The applicant, Barry Peckham, stated that it was at least 100 feet. He also
explained that gravel or another pervious material would be used on the parking space in order to
protect the tree and avoid having parking in the front.
There were no further questions and no one in the audience that wished to speak so the public
hearing was closed.
Chairman Shostrom felt the historic streetscape would be protected. Mr. Swink agreed.
Mr. Skibby made a motion to recommend approval. Mr. Swink seconded the motion and it passed
unanimously.
Mr. Krach asked if the subject of flag lots could be added to a future meeting agenda.
2008-00907
PLANNING ACTION:
33 Morse Street
SUBJECT PROPERTY:
Polly Hodges
APPLICANT:
DESCRIPTION: A request for a Conditional Use Permit intensification of use of an existing non-
conforming garage located at 33 Morse. The proposal is to convert the garage into an addition to the
existing home.
Ms. Barry explained that the applicants were converting the garage to living space and adding a 44
square foot addition to connect the new living space to the existing house. Chairman Shostrom asked
about he decorative garage doors. The applicant, Polly Hodges, said the doors will stay on the
outside and a 3-4 foot storage unit would be directly behind them. Mr. Skibby asked about the two
different widths of siding and asked which would be used on the addition. Ms. Hodges said she would
match one of them.
There being no further questions and no one in the audience wanting to speak, the public hearing was
closed.
Ms. Renwick stated she preferred the wider siding to match the house. She also wanted the garage
doors to remain due to their artistic appeal to the neighborhood.
Mr. Whitford made a motion to recommend approval with the condition that the siding on the garage
be changed to match the wider siding on the house. Mr. Watkins seconded the motion and it passed
unanimously.
2008-00925
PLANNING ACTION:
872 B Street
SUBJECT PROPERTY:
Dan Heller and Mary Beth Burton
APPLICANT:
DESCRIPTION: Site Review approval for a 390 square foot addition to the second story of an
existing residence that is part of a multi-family development located at 872 B Street.
Chairman Shostrom read the description of the project. Mr. Baker asked if the total square footage
was within the MPFA. Ms. Barry said it was. Mr. Whitford felt since it could not be seen from any
public right of way it was OK. Alex confirmed that the house was only 8-10 years old and built as a
faux craftsman.
There were no applicants present and no one in the audience wished to speak so the public hearing
was closed.
Ashland Historic Commission Minutes2
7/29/2008
(2/3/2009) Dana Smith - 7-2-08 Minutes.docPage 3
Mr. Swink made a motion to recommend approval. Mr. Whitford seconded the motion and it passed
unanimously.
2008-00596
PLANNING ACTION:
165 W Fork Street
SUBJECT PROPERTY:
Ashley Jensen
APPLICANT:
DESCRIPTION: Physical and Environmental Constraints Review Permit for the development of
hillside lands including severe constraints land. The proposal is to construct a new single-family
residential home, the associated excavation for utility installations and driveway construction. The
application also includes an Administrative Variance for the height of the retaining wall along the north
property line to exceed the allowed five-foot height limit.
Chairman Shostrom confirmed there were no conflicts of interest. Chairman Shostrom and Mr.
Skibby made a visit to the property where they talked to the applicant. Mr. Skibby also commented
that the project had been reviewed at the Historic Review Board. There was no other ex parte
contact.
Ms. Barry explained the project was subject to historic design standards. She also read the
comments from the Historic Review Board.
Owner, Ashley Jensen and architect, Michael McKee, described the changes they had made to
address some of the Historic Commissioner’s concerns. Mr. Skibby asked how much of the main
house would be seen from the road. Mr. McKee said only the pergola and a little of the roof.
Chairman Shostrom asked if it would be possible to move the house 5-9 feet up the hill to give more
street presence and a more traditional look. (It was noted that the Commissioners did not have the
most current site plan in their packets).
There being no further questions and no one in the audience wishing to speak, the public hearing
was closed.
Mr. Skibby thought there were sufficient improvements to approve the project with some additional
conditions. Mr. Watkins felt the house was non-conforming to the existing neighborhood and felt the
commission should recommend calling the project up to a public hearing. Discussion followed.
Chairman Shostrom made a motion to recommend approval with the following conditions:
That the home be moved closer to the street to mitigate elevation changes between the front
door, the driveway, and the street.
That the extra retaining wall in the rear of the house on the downhill side be eliminated and made
part of the foundation.
That the applicant return to the full Historic Commission with conceptual plans prior to building
permit submittal. Plans for Historic Commission review should include accurate floor plans,
sections of the house all the way to the road, south and north elevations showing the adjacent
house, and elevations depicting the proposed house in relation to the grade.
Mr. Swink seconded the motion and it passed with a majority vote. Mr. Watkins abstained from the
vote.
Ashland Historic Commission Minutes3
7/29/2008
(2/3/2009) Dana Smith - 7-2-08 Minutes.docPage 4
OLD BUSINESS
Review Board Schedule
A.
rd
July 3 Terry, Keith, Tom
th
July 10 Terry, Allison, Dale
th
July 17 Terry, Alex, Sam
th
July 24 Terry, Tom, Allison
st
July 31 Terry, Henry, Tom
th
August 6 Terry, Keith, Jim
Project Assignments For Planning Actions
B.
PA #2004-138234 Vista St (Sid & Karen DeBoer) Upper Poolhouse Swink
{Permit Expired)
PL#2005-01226820 “C” Street (Randy & Helen Ellison) (Temp C of O issued)Shostrom
PL#2005-0167411 First St (Ron Yamaoka) (under construction)}Skibby
PL#2005-02105145 EMain/150 Lithia Wy (Urban Dev Serv/SERA Arch) Giordano/Baker
{No Struc
final}
PL#2005-01307125 Sherman Street (Russ Dale) {Under construction}Shostrom
PA#2006-00612160 Helman (Batzer-Comm Bldgs) {New Bldg App recd-in review}Shostrom/Giordano
rd
PA#2006-0199925 N Main Street (Sandler – Masonic 3 Sty Addn) {No Bldg Permit}Krach
PA#2007-00398237 Almond Street (Don Sever – ARU) {Under Construction}Whitford
PA#2007-0079880 Wimer Street (Thomas Petersen – Kitchen Addition) {Complete}Watkins
PA#2007-00579485 A St (Hoxmeier –Mixed Use) {No structural final)Baker
PA#2007-01400542 A St (Gremmels/Delgado – Rebuild Shed {issued 6-27-08}Skibby
PA#2008-00766165 Lithia Way & 123 N First St. – Growers Market (approved)Renwick
nd
PA#2008-00925872 B St. – 2 story AdditionShostrom
PA#2008-00596165 W Fork – New SFR on hillsideSwink
Parks Archive Project – No report
C.
Lithia Springs National Register Nomination – Gun Club Lease – Chairman Shostrom discussed the
D.
background. Ms. Cathy DeForest said she felt the Council was ready to approve the new lease. Mr.
Skibby said the Heritage Committee had prepared a letter for Council. The Lease would be
th
discussed at the July 15 council meeting at 7:00 pm. Mr. Krach made several suggestions to Ms.
DeForest on addressing the environmental concerns of the site. He felt a study was needed and
agreed to speak at the Council meeting. Mr. Skibby, Mr. Swink and Chairman Shostrom stated they
would also attend.
Single Family Residential Design Standards – No report
E.
Co-Sponsorship with Conservation Commission for Fall Workshop – No report
F.
DISCUSSION ITEMS
–
There was consensus to renew the membership with National Alliance of Preservation Commissions.
1.
Special Assessment Program – Mr. Whitford explained that SHPO was now authorized to extend the
2.
Special Assessments for an additional 15 years. However, each jurisdiction needed to pass an
Ashland Historic Commission Minutes4
7/29/2008
(2/3/2009) Dana Smith - 7-2-08 Minutes.docPage 5
ordinance or resolution in order to extend the option to the residents.
Mr. Whitford made a motion to encourage the Ashland City Council to approve the additional 15 year
extension. Ms. Renwick seconded the motion and it passed unanimously.
NEW BUSINESS
– None
ANNOUNCEMENTS
The next Historic Commission meeting will be on August 6, 2008 at 7:00 pm in the Siskiyou Room.
Special Historic Commission meeting will be on August 21, 2008 at 12:30 pm in the Siskiyou Room.
ADJOURNMENT
It was the unanimous decision of the Commission to adjourn the meeting at 10:30 p.m.
Ashland Historic Commission Minutes5
7/29/2008