HomeMy WebLinkAbout2004-081 Findings - ArmoryBEFORE THE ASHLAND CITY COUNCIL
IN THE MATTER OF PLANNING ACTION #2003-105, A REQUEST )
FOR A Conditional Use Permit TO ALLOW 6858 SQ.FT. OF THE )
INTERIOR OF THE NATIONAL GUARD .ARMORY FACILITY, )
LOCATED AT 1420 EAST MAIN ST., TO BE USED FOR A VARIETY )
OF EVENTS INCLUDING TRADE SHOWS, FLEA MARKETS, )
COMMUNITY EVENTS, AND PRIVATE PARTIES. )
FINDINGS,
CONCLUSIONS
AND ORDERS
APPLICANT: Oregon Military Department
RECITALS:
1) Tax lot 1300 of 391E 10D is located at 1420 East Main Street and is
zoned SO, with a comprehensive plan designation of Southern Oregon
University lands.
2) The applicant is requesting a Conditional Use Permit to allow a portion of
the interior space at the National Guard Armory facility (approximately
6,858sq.ft. in area) to be used for a variety of events including Trade Shows,
Flea Markets, Community Event:s, and Private Parties.
3) The criteria for a Conditional Use Permit are described in Chapter 18.104
and are as follows:
A. That the use would be in conformance with afl standards within the
zoning district in which the use is proposed to be located, and in conformance
with relevant Comprehensive plan poficies that are not implemented by any
City, State, or Federal law or program.
B. That adequate capacity of City facilities for water, sewer, paved
access to and through the development, electricity, urban storm drainage,
and adequate transportation can and will be provided to and through the
subject property.
C. That the conditional use will have no greater adverse material effect
on the fivability of the impact area when compared to the development of the
subject lot with the target use of' the zone. When evaluating the effect of the
proposed use on the impact area, the following factors of fivability of the
impact area shaft be considered in relation to the target use of the zone:
1) Similarity in scale, bulk:, and coverage.
2) Generation of traffic and effects on surrounding streets. Increases in
pedestrian, bicycle, and mass transit use are considered beneficial
regardless of capacity of facilities.
3) Architectural compatibility with the impact area
1 - G:\legal\PAUL\PLANNING~Armory\flndings revised for reconsideration as adopted 5-04.wpd
4) Air quafity, including the generation of dust, odors, or other
environmental pollutants.
5) Generation of noise, light, and glare.
6) The development of adjacent properties as envisioned in the
Comprehensive Plan.
7) Other factors found to ,De relevant by the Hearing Authority for
review of the proposed use.
4) The Planning Commission, following proper public notice, held a Public
Hearing on September 9, 2003 at which time testimony was received and
exhibits were presented. The Planning Commission approved the application
as presented, with additional conditions of approval pertaining to the
appropriate use of the site and hours of operation.
5) An appeal was filed in a timely manner by the Oregon Military Department.
The appeal was heard before the Ashland City Council on November 18,
2003 at which time testimony was received and exhibits were presented. The
City Council approved the application as presented, with modifications to the
conditions of approval attached Iby the Planning Commission.
Now, therefore, The Ashland City, Council finds, concludes and recommends
as follows:
SECTION 1. EXHIBITS
For the purposes of reference to these Findings, the attached index of
exhibits, data, and testimony will be used.
Staff Exhibits lettered with an "S"
Proponent's Exhibits, lettered with a "P"
Opponent's Exhibits, lettered with an "O"
Hearing Minutes, Notices, Miscellaneous Exhibits lettered with an "M"
SECTION 2. CONCLUSORY FINDINGS
2.1. The City Council finds that it has received all information necessary to
make a decision based on the Staff Report, public hearing testimony and the
exhibits received.
2.2. The City Council finds that as no external modifications of the facility are
proposed, the proposal will have no impact on bulk, scale or architectural compatibility.
2.3. The City Council finds that site has adequate capacity of City facilities for
water, sewer, paved access to arid through the development, electricity, urban
storm drainage, and adequate transportation is provided to the subject
property. Additionally the subject property was found to have adequate on-
site parking for the intended uses.
2 - G:\legal\PAUL\PLANNINGtArmory\findings revised for reconsideration as adopted 5-04.wpd
2.4. The City Council finds that the original approval in 1987 was for a National
Guard Armory, which was indicated by the Military Department at that time to
be used as a "military installation as well as for community functions .... "The
approved outright permitted uses for the subject property, therefore, are for a
military installation and community functions.
These outright permitted uses are not subject to the limitations of hours or
numbers of time per month or other conditions imposed on the conditional
uses described below. The council interprets these outright permitted uses to
include, but not be limited to, military activities and community functions which
are to be defined as governmental meetings; educational-, informational-,
charitable-, health-, and recreational-type community gatherings such as
public school graduations, blood ,drives, weight-watchers meetings,
gymnastics practices or events, holiday meals, private weddings, birthday
parties and anniversaries, non-profit events, and similar community uses and
events, where such community functions do not include live or amplified music
or alcohol.
2.5. Community functions are to be distinguished from commercial functions
because such functions can have different impacts, beyond the large
gathering of people, upon the neighborhood. Even community events, where
alcohol is served or with live or amplified music, present their own set of
adverse impacts distinct from such impacts where they are not present. The
council finds that the uses proposed by the applicant involving commercial
events (held to make a profit) such as trade shows, public dances, concerts,
flea markets, or farmers markets do not constitute community functions.
Because such uses have not been agreed upon in advance by the city as
required in section 18.64.030.A, the applicant is required to obtain a
conditional use permit for them. In addition, the council interprets those
community events where alcohol is served or involving live or amplified music
as not constituting "community functions" and are therefor not outright
permitted.
2.6. The City Council finds that the impact of the outright permitted uses
posed by the applicant (as noted in 2.4) shall have no greater adverse
material effect on the livability of the impact area when compared to the
development of the property by Southern Oregon University, according to its
zone requirements. However, commercial uses as noted in 2.5 could have an
adverse impact on the adjacent residential neighborhood. Therefore, to
ensure that those uses do not unduly impact the livability of the impact area,
based upon comments from nearby residential property owners, the city will
impose conditions on the use of the auditorium on the property related to the
hours or operation for the uses limited by this conditional use permit.
The conditional use activities are to be limited to 8:00 am to 9:00 pm Sunday
through Thursday, and 8:00 am through 11:00 pm on Friday and Saturday.
Further, the Council finds that there shall be no more than 12 conditional use
3 - G:\legal\PAUL\PLANNING~Armory\findings revised for reconsideration as adopted 5-04.wpd
activities occurring past 8:00 pm during any calendar month. The hour
limitation refers to the ending time of any particular event, and does not
include time involved, limited to no more than two hours, after the event has
concluded for attendees to leave the building and the parking lot, and for
applicant to clean up and close down the facility.
The City Council finds that with the attached conditions, the conditional uses
will have no greater adverse material effect on the livability of the impact area
when compared to the development of the subject lot with the target use of the
Southern Oregon University zone,.
SECTION 3. DECISION
3.1 Based on the record of the public hearing on this matter, the City Council
concludes that the following described conditional use activities in the
auditorium of the National Guard Armory located at 1420 East Main Street are
supported by evidence within the record and the following activities are
allowed as a conditional use subject to certain conditions as listed below:
Commercial events in the auditorium (where goods or services are sold for a
profit) such as trade shows, public dances, concerts, flea markets, farmers
markets held within the building, holiday bazaars, and similar events.
Any Commercial or Community function where alcohol is served, or live or
amplified music is played.
Therefore, based on our overall conclusions, and upon the proposal being
subject to each of the following conditions, we approve Planning Action #
2003-105. Further, if any one or more of the conditions below are found to be
invalid, for any reason whatsoever, then Planning Action # 2003-105 is
denied. The following are the conditions and they are attached to the
approval:
The above uses shall be conditioned as follows:
All proposals of the applicant shall be conditions of approval unless
otherwise modified here.
No Conditional Use of the interior of the Armory shall coincide with the
exterior conditional use by the Rogue Valley Growers and Crafters
Market Tuesdays 7:00 am - 3:00 pm, April through November. (Use by
the Rogue Valley Growers and Crafters Market is regulated by a
previously issued conditional use permit.)
o
The applicants shall obtain a Sign Permit prior to any signs being
displayed on the site. All requirements of Chapter 18.96 shall be met.
4 - G:\legal\PAUL\PLANNING~Armory\findings revised for reconsideration as adopted 5-04.wpd
The operation shall comply with the noise levels as required in 9.08.170
of the Ashland Municipal Code.
The applicant shall provide a contact person for the facility who is
available to address any concerns that may arise. This person shall be
identified and contact information submitted to the Ashland Planning
Division and the Ashland Police Department prior to operation of any
conditional use.
All Conditional Uses shall comply with applicable fire and building code
requirements prior to operation of the Conditional Use activities.
o
Conditional Uses shall be limited to 8:00am to 9:00 pm Sunday
through Thursday, and 8:00 am through 11:00 pm on Friday and
Saturday.
o
No more than 12 Conditional Use activities shall occur past 8:00 pm
during any month.
Any new outdoor lighting systems installed in relation to conditional use
activities shall be designed and operated so that the area ten feet
beyond the property line of the premises receives no more than 0.25 of
a foot candle of light from the premises lighting system. Further, any
outdoor lighting systems installed in relation to conditional use activities
shall be recessed or shielded sufficiently so as to ensure that no light
source is visible from or causes glare on public rights-of-way or
adjacent property. All outdoor lighting shall be shielded so as to not
emit light above a horizontal plane located at light source level.
10.
Applicant shall maintain a log of uses at the Armory, and the log shall
be available for review by the City after advance notice is given to the
Armory.
Alan W. DeBoer, Mayor
City of Ashland
Date
5 - G:\legal\PAUL\PLANNING~Armory\flndings revised for reconsideration as adopted 5-04.wpd